Home » Mental Health » Psychology » Ghosters Always Come Back, But Should You Let Them?

Ghosters Always Come Back, But Should You Let Them?

When someone ghosts you, it is an awful feeling. It happens more than it should. One day you’re a few weeks into a budding relationship, and the next? Radio silence.

Why did they disappear? Did I do something wrong? Is the next person going to do the same? 

You do your best to move on, and then your phone pings a few weeks or months down the line. It’s them, and they’ve popped back up with that all-too-familiar, “Hey, what’s up?” text. 

This behavior is, in equal parts, annoying and disorienting. Where did they go, and why the hell are they back? 

Why do ghosters come back?

Ghosters come back for a variety of reasons, which we will get into. When unpacking the motivation behind a ghoster reappearing, it’s essential to consider the full context.

How long have they been away? Did you date for long before they ghosted? How serious was your relationship with them?

This will help frame your response if you even bother having one. 

So why do ghosters come back and what do they want?

woman sitting on the couch looking frustrated at her phone beside the title Why Ghosters Always Come Back
3 Reasons Why Ghosters Always Come Back

1. They want sex. 

Sometimes ghosters come back because they are looking for a hookup and think that they can achieve that by rekindling something with you. 

There’s also the illustrious pull of sexual nostalgia. Your ghoster may be feeling unfulfilled by their current dating life or life more generally. According to experts, feeling socially disconnected and lonely can trigger nostalgic thoughts of ex-partners. 

As dating expert Matthew Hussey eloquently stated, “people will reappear in your life because there is a void in their own.”

Some people try to fill that void with sex and temporary intimacy. Once that itch has been scratched, your ghoster will likely disappear again. 

2. They want to know if you’re still an option. 

Sometimes ghosters pop up simply to see if they can. It’s not because they are remorseful over ghosting you. Nor do they want to pursue a normal, healthy relationship.

They simply want to know if you are still single and available. 

It’s a bit like securing a backup plan. It’s not that your ghoster wants to be with you. They simply want to know if they can reach out when they are lonely.

3. They are bored.

A ghoster may have reappeared because they are bored. Perhaps the single life isn’t all it’s cracked up to be, or maybe they are in a social lull. Whatever the reason, they are using you to fill the void.

Some people do this maliciously, knowing full well they are being manipulative. Others might genuinely convince themselves that they miss you on some level.

Either way, the result will be the same – they will disappear again, and you will be hurt. 

4. They’ve changed. 

Occasionally, a ghoster might come back because a significant amount of time has passed, and they’ve changed. They want to take responsibility for their behavior and make amends with you. 

This type of ghoster will acknowledge their mistake and show you with their actions that they’re serious about trying to date you again. 

If this is something you are willing to entertain (and you most certainly don’t owe them anything), here are some things you can do to determine if a resurrected ghoster deserves a second chance. 

But before we do that, it’s important to note something for anyone wondering if ghosters come back because they are holding out hope that one will. In most ghosting situations, the ghoster has done you a favor, and this is not somebody you want in your life. 

Their ghosting behavior says more about them than you. People ghost because they are making a deliberate choice, and it is 100% on them, and there is nothing you could have done to make this person behave differently. 

Let’s discuss what to do if a ghoster comes back and you’re suddenly staring at the dreaded “Hey stranger!” text. 

What To Do If A Ghoster Comes Back

First, let’s remember that context is everything.

What type of ghoster are we dealing with here? Relationship expert Mark Rosenfeld categorizes ghosters into three primary buckets: short-term, mid-range, and long-range. 

His perspective deals mainly with male ghosters, but women are also capable of the same bad behavior. 

Close up picture of a woman's hands scrolling on a phone beside the title What to do if a ghoster comes back
How to handle ghosters who come back

Short-Term Ghosters

According to Rosenfeld, these are the guys you’ve only been talking to or dating for a short time. Initially, they were responsive to texts and making plans. Then, out of nowhere, they ghost for a few days or a week. 

When a short-term ghoster pops back up, the first thing you want to do is ask what happened.

Rosenfeld suggests assuming the best rather than jumping to accusations. Did something happen?

See what he or she says. 

If nothing happened and the ghoster acts defensive or claims to have just been busy, that’s a huge red flag. 

On the other hand, if something did happen and the ghoster opens up to you, it becomes an entirely different discussion.

Let them know in the future that if something is happening, it’s okay to tell you. Don’t just disappear without saying anything.

On this last point, Rosenfeld gives one word of caution – if your ghoster deals with stressful life events by shutting people out, that could be a sign they are not ready for a relationship. 

Mid-Range Ghosters

In my personal opinion, mid-range ghosters are the absolute worst kind. These are ghosters who are gone for several weeks or even months. You’ve just started to get over the ghosting, and then (like clockwork) they’re back. 

Rosenfeld urges people to call these types out immediately and directly. 

If you want to respond to that obnoxiously casual, “Hey, how are you?” text (and you definitely do not have to), he suggests teasing out their reason for contact. You can reply back just as casually.

“I’m fine. How are you?”

What they do next will tell you a lot. If they do not initiate a conversation with you at this point that is apologetic or owning up to the fact they ghosted you, end the conversation.

Imagine, after two months of radio silence, dealing with a conversation like this:

Ghoster: Hey, what’s up?

You: Not much. You?

Ghoster: I’m good. What are you doing?

If it makes you want to tear your hair out and throw your phone across a room, do not continue speaking to this person. Tell them to lose your number. They are not a serious person, nor do they have an ounce of remorse for ghosting you. 

Goodbye.

Long-Range Ghosters

That brings us to our final category: long-range ghosters. These are the people who pop back up after six months or more. 

Interestingly enough, Rosenfeld had the most optimism for this type of ghoster. There’s been enough time that they may be back for the right reasons. 

Of course, context matters a lot. What was the situation between you two before the ghosting? Was it still casual? Had you been dating for long? 

When a long-range ghoster comes back, it’s essential to call them out. What happened?

Then listen to what they have to say. 

Much like with mid-range ghosts, if they don’t immediately offer an apology and take full ownership of the ghosting, end the conversation. 

But if they show remorse, and you’re emotionally up for it, you can consider giving them a second chance.

If you’re looking for more advice on handling this situation, Renee Slansky has a great video on the subject:

Only Allow A Ghoster To Come Back If They Can Do The Following (Unprovoked):

  • Apologize for ghosting you
  • Express awareness that ghosting you was terrible.
  • Take ownership for ghosting you. 
  • Explain why they are back now.
  • Demonstrate a sincere desire to make it up to you. 

If they can do those things and you’re interested, the next step is to set clear standards. Let them know:

  • You can’t pick up where you left off. 
  • It will take time to rebuild trust. 
  • The two of you are starting over.

Take it slow.

You’ll need time to see if this person has truly changed. Can they provide consistency and open, honest communication? 

This means letting them take the lead.

They’re the one who ghosted you. Now it’s their turn to show initiative and prove they are a serious person worthy of your time.

Ghosters Will Keep Coming Back As Long As You Let Them

More often than not, ghosters are best left in the past where they belong. Ghosting is a terrible thing to do to another person. It shows a lack of emotional maturity and empathy. 

Despite that, many ghosters will inevitably try to pop back up in your inbox or messages to say hello

The good news is you do not have to acknowledge them at all. 

If you decide to give a ghoster a second chance, make sure you are examining the situation objectively and setting clear expectations for the relationship. 

Your emotional well-being and sanity are precious assets. Protect them at all costs. 

Young woman looking at her phone with a shocked expression on her face behind the title Why ghosters come back (+ what to do about it)
Why ghosters always come back PIN

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.